How I will Judge Movies

I'm going to take what I think to be the five main crafts of filmmaking and judge them seperatley on a 5 star system. Then, I will give my overall rating in terms of a percent. The five key things I will be looking at are:

1) Writing
2) Directing
3) Acting
4) Editing
5) Cinematography/Sound

In this case, cinematography will include costume, makeup, sets, etc. All the elements that make a film look the way it does. I also include sound because it is not a big enough category to be considered by itself, and also involves how the audience experiences the film. In some movies in won't apply.